Westboro Baptist Church: 'God Hates Ohio State University'
AND
Reflect on these two sites. They discuss the Westboro Baptist Church and their views on Ohio State and effectively America.
How is this church invading the privacy of our school as a public university?
Why are their ideals infringing on our school's efforts towards inclusion, exception, and diversity?
How is the church abusing their rights of "freedom of speech" by protesting our freedom of expression?
Feel free to disagree.
Hey everyone! When I reviewed the articles, I noticed each had comments at the bottom. It might be useful to look at what other people are saying about this group and what they have to say about the group's rhetoric. I thought it was really interesting!
ReplyDeleteThe WBC is not invading the privacy of our school mainly because this is a public university. They protest in public. They do however greatly infringe upon the school's ideals of inclusion and diversity with their hate filled speeches and rallies. The 1'st amendment should not protect hate filled speech that is ignorant and full of despicable things. I truly feel that the only reason the university is not taking a stand by not allowing these crazy people to protest is because they don't wish to be sued. I for one feel like we should take the lead that the Foo Fighters has presented and protest against the WBC. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6e5hRLbCaCs watch this video and see. beware of bad language.
ReplyDeleteahem! remember our first goal is rhetorical analysis! we are not concerned with the WBC and what they stand for, we are concerned with HOW these articles present the issues to us! refer to "Consider the Following..." above.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading these two articles, I noticed some differences in how each source presented similar information. The Lantern seemed to be more open or liberal in its presentation. It immediately stated that the WBC is "a Kansas church, which commonly protests with its 'God Hates Fags' signs...." in the very first sentence. Throughout the article, the Lantern portrays Timothy Phelps, a member of the WBC, as an old bigot by including quotes such as "filthy creatures" and "disobedience to Commandments of God...nation for destruction." One can draw similarities between Phelps' rhetoric and that of a Klansman (as Richard pointed out).
ReplyDeleteOn the contrary, Christian Post presents the article in a different light. It is more conservative in its word choice and rhetoric when compared to the Lantern. It paints the same picture of the WBC as an anti-gay group but uses different tools to do it. Instead of focusing on the prejudice and somewhat maniacal opinions of Timothy Phelps, it merely states what the WBC is doing at OSU.
To answer the questions above, I don't believe the WBC is invading our privacy, but merely using OSU as a tool to express its views and opinions. It's almost as if the WBC protesters want to instigate violent retaliations with their hateful, anti-gay signs/chants. The ideals of the WBC are somewhat old-fashioned as opposed to OSU's more modern and progressive inclusion and pro-gay views. I don't think that their protesters will affect our privacy because of the fact that OSU is such a large university and the WBC is minute in contrast.
I feel that both of these articles are a little too passive toward WBC, but on the other hand, could use a little more background facts about them. I do not believe that WBC is invading our privacy as a public university, nor are they infinging on our attempts to welcome the gay community. And they are not abusing their rights to free speech. The right to privacy could be argued, but Constitutionally, it does not apply in this situation. I have met them in person and spoken with them about their beliefs. I believe that their entire church is a scam. They push people to their breaking points and then file civil law suits for "having their constitutional rights" broken. They usually win these law suits, and it does not hurt that their entire board of elders in WBC are all educated lawyers... They do not deserve anything when they come to campus, but to be ignored.
ReplyDeleteTo complicate Grace's claim ("a little too passive"), is it the job of a "news" publication to frame their commentary on a subject with a moral or ethical outlook? I do agree that we could use some more context about the WBC. Both articles, esp. the Lantern's, use quotes (Anil pointed to this as well)... and I wonder how many are taken out of context or selected for their shock value. The Lantern, being an OSU publication, clearly displays bias both bc the WBC is attacking our university AND as Anil has pointed out, it is more liberal in its treatment. For me, a clear indicator of its bias appears in the student quote it which he describes the WBC's rhetoric as "hate speech." The author included this quote for a reason... (can you spot other examples? or can you complicate mine?)
ReplyDeleteI invite you guys to consider the question I posed at the beginning of my post: is it the job of the news to frame their subject matter with an ethical or moral outlook? are these articles doing that? if so, how are they doing it? (good work so far everyone! for those of you who haven't yet responded, there's still tons to examine in these publications!)
While reading the Lantern article about WBC I felt like I was reading something written to make me angry. Being a strong Christian and reading this made me want to immediately contact the WBC and explain to them why they are wrong. I feel like the Lantern is using pathos a great deal in their article. By using specific quotes from member of the WBC, the Lantern really played with my emotions. The quotes had a very strong hatred towards our university and while reading that it made it very personal to me.
ReplyDeleteWhile reading the other article, I didn't feel as much of hatred towards the WBC as I did it in the previous article. This article seemed to just be explaining what WBC is about and not exactly their hatred towards us, so in a way this article was just giving me facts and nothing else that really seemed to play with my emotions like the Lantern article did.
After reading both articles, I do not believe they are invading our university's privacy mainly because we are a public university. If we take pride in letting people express themselves here then it is hard to say no to this organization and what they are doing. I feel as though their ideals will not affect our university in the slightest bit. We take pride in our university and students here will not allow for a group like this to sway them into different directions. Once again, this group is not abusing their right to freedom of speech. They are completely free to say what they want. It is just up to us students and faculty to decide if we want to listen or not. I suggest not listening.
In the comments of the first post, an anonymous user says "I vote we just ignore them so we dont feed their addiction to attention." What do you think about how the public always gives Westboro attention whenever they go somewhere to speak or protest? Do you think the media should stop giving Westboro the attention that makes them so infamous?
ReplyDeleteTo answer Mira's last question I have to say yes. The press is in itself infamous for blowing things out of proportion. I am willing to bet that there are a lot of other organizations and groups around the country like this that just don't get as much media attention and therefore are not as well known and not as hated as other countries are. As for the pubic attention, it's hard to ignore. If you see a group protest like this on the streets it is almost impossible to resist looking at the bare minimum. Many people will approach it to find out what is going on and at that point that have been lured to the point where they can see what is occurring. It is better to stay away. They do have the freedom of speech so they can say what they want, if you disagree, just leave them alone.
ReplyDeleteAlright,according to Melissa's suggestion, I tried to view these two articles focusing on how they express the issue.Well, I have to say, at the first glimpse ,the articles seemed fair enough.They posted background of WBC,past year's events,voice from the WBC, OSU and a normal student.However,when I went to detail, I still sensed prejudice.For example,at the beginning, one of the article used word"controvesial" followed by "...known for its flashy anti-gay protests and stunts at military funerals, among other controversial activity...","...the group posted a more vague statement on its infamous website..."and so on.As for content, the article quoted comments from WBC using sentence like"You foolish smart guys","We're back!! You lucky ducks!".These sentences inflammatory and tend to leave a negative impression upon WBC.On the other hand,the article quoted the speech of the OSU spokesman which seemed much more rational and convincing.Besides, the article only quoted a student who is against WBC without supporting voice outside WBC.These quotes actually worsen the viewers' impressions on WBC.
ReplyDeleteIn conclusion, what I mean is, there are a lot of people saying about the issue, much information about it.However, the author holds the right to pick up the voices among them,he/she may have the opportunity to make it more personal even in an unconscious way.I suppose news has to be fair and just. I believe the news should always and only state the whole picture and leave the viewers to judge.
To comment on Melissa's post, I do not think that it is not the responsibility of the news to give a moral or ethical outlook. The fundamental idea behind having news is to have quick, easy access to information, which involves no such outlooks. With this being said, it is quite common to include some form of bias, as sensationalism sells in journalism, as demonstrated by both news articles including WBC's anti-gay views in the title of their article, which could be considered a rather extreme view. This shows that both sources want to use the most shocking aspect of this issue to draw readers in.
ReplyDeleteMuch like Cody, I had a very emotional response to these articles! Not only do the views of the WBC contradict with every one of my personal morals, they also insult some of my closest friendships. Immediately after reading the article from The Lantern, I had a great urge to chuck my computer across my dorm room! While I did not actually do this, the rage this article created lead to my next inclination to send my best friend a link to both of these articles. Given that I support gay rights, and having a gay best friend, I do have a largely biased opinion in regards to the WBC.
ReplyDeleteTo comment in response to Melissa's last comment, I feel that Phil's comment was right in saying that "The fundamental idea behind having news is to have quick, easy access to information", and that "...it is quite common to include some form of bias, as sensationalism sells in journalism." While I do agree with what he has said, I do feel that it is the responsibility to try to make their articles as unbiased as possible. Normally, newspaper articles will aim to achieve this by included quotes from both supporting and opposing perspectives. In the Lantern, however, this was not accomplished, and while The Lantern is a newspaper (which should holds itself to the same standards as other newspapers), it is a reflection of our university, a university that possesses a strong belief of inclusion and diversity (and not the hatred that the WBC preaches).
Looking at the group's original questions, it is evident that these articles and this specific issue connect well with our course theme. While, the WBC has the first amendment right to freedom of speech and protest, they do push the boundaries a bit too far. Since OSU is a public university, it makes it harder to distinguish whether they indeed are or are not invading the university's privacy. But, given the reputation of OSU acceptance and inclusion, I think that the WBC is invading our school's privacy by directly insulting a university standard. Also, their protests on the school's property infringes on the school's efforts, and shows the group blatant disrespect for the university and its morally well-rounded students!
Going off of what Cody said, the Lantern article made me incredibly angry. Cody and I were talking about this issue and just talking about it makes me mad. I do believe they are not invading our privacy as well based off the fact that we are a public institution. But I believe that the university will not be affected by this in any way because everyone here is so inclusive and well-rounded. And these people are free to say whatever they want, but I strongly disagree with everything they say and that it's just better to ignore them all together.
ReplyDeleteWhile what the Westboro Baptist Church is doing may not be even close to morally sound, I don't think that they are intruding on any of our legal rights. They have their freedoms just as much as any other American citizens, and for us to protest what they do, and for us to try and say that they are violating our rights is something that is just as against American freedoms as what they do.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading some comments, I agree that the Lantern gave a biased outlook on the WBC. Naturally it would because it's based at OSU, like Melissa said, and the WBC is saying negative things about OSU. Although the news is supposed to as objective as possible, the writer will always influence the portrayal of information with their own opinions depending on where they come from, who they are, and what the article is about.
ReplyDeleteI have to Agree with both Cody and Cameron here when they say that the lantern article made them extremely upset. I completely disagree with what the WBC stand for and how they present themselves to the public. It is hard for our university to do anything agains the WBC due to the fact that we are a public university. The church is using it's freedom of speech to the fullest extent by publicly discrediting a University that accepts people from all walks of life. It is not WBC's duty to tell someone how they should live their life. It is okay to express one's view but once you begin to specifically target individuals on campus that is crossing the line.
ReplyDelete