Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Group 3 Post 1

The following article from CommonPlace deals with the idea that tattoos are a deterrent for potential employers.


What do you think the underlying issue is in this article?

Do you think the author mentioning tattoos throughout history and on famous persons is relevant to the article as a whole?

Do you feel the author makes strong enough arguments in the article?

Would you feel comfortable if one of your health professionals had visible tattoos? (I understand this is more of a personal opinion question, but it is relevant to a point the author makes later in the article)

Please reflect on anything else you find interesting, upsetting, or agree with in the article.


23 comments:

  1. The underlying issue within the article is that the author feels that there is a large gap between how his generation and the generation before him feel about tattoos. He wants to defend the personal choices he has made and explain to people that having tattoos does not in anyway make you a bad person. In fact the whole article can be summed up to "Don't judge a book by it's cover".
    To accomplish his goal, the author explains a short history of tattoos, this is to give readers back story into what they are and their meaning. I would feel perfectly fine if my doctor had multiple tattoos. Mainly because he is a licensed medical professional that endured and passed 8 years of medical training to get where he is at that moment. To say that just because he has tattoos he is going to be a bad doctor for me is ludicrous. In fact I would probably ask him the meaning of the tattoos that stick out to me. Overall I agree with what the author has to say, though it has made me think about the placement of some of the tattoos I wish to get over the years because though we live in an ever changing world, certain stigmas still persist.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I read the whole article carefully and can feel a strong emotion of the author--anger or what to say,an frustrated confusion about why there are still people who treat tattoos as bad things.He argues in today's society, people should be more tolerant toward expression symbols like tattoos.The mismatch between tattoo culture and the general public,especially employers',expectations is the underlying issue.
    Definitely, the mention of the tattoos through history and on famous people is to support the author's claim.
    In my opinion ,the author makes good efforts supporting his claims but I still suppose it can be more persuasive.Just like the author himself states,"We strive to be the home of the free, accepting everyone for who they are and what they believe", people who hold a negative attitude towards tattoos have the same right to do so just as those people who use tattoos to,according to the author,"present positive ideas".
    Therefore,I accept the author's argument claiming tattoo is not always a bad thing,but tattoos do have some negative elements related and I do understand why employers prefer not to hire people with tattoos.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I disagree with David on the idea that it is understandable that an employer would not prefer to hire someone with tattoo's. I believe that a tattoo is simply an expression of one's self. And, the only way a tattoo should be brought into question in the work force is if it is obcene or has offensive symbolic meaning to others (like the swasitcka).

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with what Zach had to say. After reading the article, I felt a very strong message of injustice coming from the author's words. It is clear that he was done wrong in some way by a potential employer, as cited in his personal story in the beginning of the article. I also feel as though his example of a doctor is indicative of what the author was trying to explain: while there are some people who will fill the stereotype, there will always be exceptions.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Appearance is everything in our world. Therefore I find when the author says, “I’m sitting in a potential employer’s office, pulling my shirt sleeve down, turning my body to the side while constantly sucking my lip in, trying to hide the hole of where a piercing was placed only minutes ago.”, to be very interesting. It seems to me that the author knows that tattoos are frowned upon in the work world, but is then surprised when the employer says, “I don’t think we will be able to utilize you; your appearance isn’t what we usually go for.” Based on this I believe that the author’s argument of whether or not it’s fair for your appearance to be a factor in acquiring a job to be irrelevant, because based on his experience appearance it is a qualifying factor for getting a job. Does anybody agree or disagree? P.S still answer the questions above.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The issue the author's personal problems over tattoos and how they are viewed. He feels judged based on his appearance. The author's examples of famous people that have tattoos are almost irrelevant. Sure, Dennis Rodman was well known for his absurd amount of markings on his arms but it didn't make him any better at basketball. He was still judged based on his appearance but his profession was less strict on appearance. In a serious workplace, appearance is important. First impressions are made off of how a person looks. The author's arguments may very well be true but I do not see any evidence or proof showing that what he is saying is true. He may just be writing his opinions and while it appears he is making good claims about judgments of people, they may not be fully acceptable. Like I said, appearance is crucial in first impressions. If my doctor came into the room to perform some form on treatment as minor as a check up to as serious as life saving surgery, I would like to see him dressed properly and looking professional. A job of such high standards should require the best out of all its employees so while the doctor may be the best in the country and still have tattoos up and down his arms, I would prefer to not know that.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Like Grace said, I would understand why a company wouldn't hire you if you had a tat of like.. a dragon with a mouth full of babies and the Kebler elf burning bibles right across your forehead. But most often then not, tattoo's hold some sort of significance and shouldn't be a hindrance to someone applying for a job.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Times are changing.. The difference between our generation and the one before us is that we are a little more tolerant than they are when it comes to an individual's looks. Personally.. I wouldn't mind it if my doctor had a sleeve or two. They tell a story and I think that tattoo's add a lot of character to a person. Unless of course that person got a tattoo out of a drunken fit and didn't know what they were doing. But even so, that tells a story and tells a lot about that persons character.. even if it's a bad story.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The underlying issue in this article is the author's anger for stereotyping he feels in being given to him and all others with tattoos. He makes that apparent in many parts of his article like when "I know many people frown upon seeing today’s youth covered in tattoos as “deviant,” but I didn’t intend to let something so minor be so detrimental to my future." His arguments don't work for me and I think they are pretty weak. First off, putting a permanent marking on your body isn't a "minor" thing. It is something that should be well thought out and planned in advance. There are some people who get a tattoo just to get one or because they are not in their right state of mind. I think this is partially why tattoos get a bad rap. Secondly I think if he did not want getting a tattoo to affect his career options he would have thought more carefully about it since he obviously knew that it would have a negative affect. "I’m sitting in a potential employer’s office, pulling my shirt sleeve down, turning my body to the side while constantly sucking my lip in, trying to hide the hole of where a piercing was placed only minutes ago. I am trying to cover the multiple tattoos visible on my body, including a half sleeve down my right arm, and a large bold ambigram, a design that reads a word one way and a another word when viewed from a different angle, running down my other." If he didn't think they would hurt him he wouldn't have hid them. Sadly, appearance means everything in this world and so when someone doesn't look "professional" they are thrown out. The bringing up of famous people with tattoos is not relevant to his main argument. Musicians are themselves artists and therefore it is more accepted for them to have artistic drawlings on their bodies. Doctors on the other hand for one aren't artists and for two need to be in a position that isn't offensive to anyone. Some people might look at a doctor with a visible tattoo and find it offensive to them or they might scare a child if the child has never been exposed to tattoos or doesn't understand. I personally wouldn't care if my doctor had visible tattoos because I know he is still a professional and went through years of training. The sad truth is that tattoos are controversial in this day and age and will be for a while.

    ReplyDelete
  11. The underlying issue of this article is pretty much describing how the author feels about how he/others have been discriminated because of the tattoos they have.
    I don't know if I think the author really makes very strong arguments because, although I already do agree with him for the most part, I don't know if this article would be enough to convince me to agree with his viewpoint. There is nothing solid in this article that necessarily counters anything someone with an opposing viewpoint might say.
    I think the point he makes about certain celebrities sporting tattoos is really just something he put in for the same reason a company would use a celebrity in an advertisement on tv.
    Personally, I don't think I'd mind too much if I had doctor or dentist or someone who had tattoos as long as I can tell by other means that they are competent and know what they are doing.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The underlying issue within this article is the general stereotype employers and the general public have about people with tattoos. Tattoos are viewed as being on criminals and slackers and whether it is truth or not, the public has accepted that as the general stereotype for tattooed people. I think the author's mention of the historical background of tattoos holds relevance to his argument due to the fact that it gives a general basis for the challenge against the accepted stereotype that tattoos have. However, its seems rather pithy of him to include celebrities into his argument because all those examples serve to do is to make the comment "oh ya, so this famous person has them, so I can too" which is in itself a weak argument. The author did make some good points in his argument however it never really went past the point of being a personal rant against his own personal experiences: which is what he wanted to accomplish. However, his arguments are not relative to the population as a whole and will not sway anyone in their opinions on tattoos

    ReplyDelete
  13. I agree with Mira's comment about seeing the doctors other credentials and would even go so far as to elaborate on it in the sense of race and sex. While the tattoo issue is not nearly as widespread among the medical community, the issue over gender and race still plays a huge roll in people's preconception of a doctor. Generally white male doctors are the ones in which people associate "a good doctor" while a black female doctor will bring about skepticism from their patients more so than the white male. There is no basis for this unreasonable distrust, yet our society has come to associate the position of doctor with the white male. These acts of racism can be applied to many fields and are in effect the "tattoos" for females and people of different ethnicity everywhere

    ReplyDelete
  14. Great, great work on this topic!! Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
  15. The underlying issue is that tattoos still have negative connotations despite the actual character of the person with tattoos. Making references to Travis Barker, Jeremy Shockey, and Dennis Rodman are somewhat irrelevant because those people are not in professions that are prestigious, such as medical professions, government professions, etc. If the author found a notable figure in a more prestigious profession that was accepted despite having tattoos would've been more relevant in supporting the authors point. The arguments that the author makes are not strong enough because he lets his bad job experience and his own bias towards tattoos influence his analysis of the issue and arguments presented throughout the article.

    If I knew or saw that my doctor or surgeon had visible tattoos on his/her arms, hands, face, legs, etc., then I would have second thoughts about how professional he or she is. I don't want a doctor who resembles a tattoo artist or a rock artist or a gang member. In my opinion, tattoos are all about appearance. They send a certain image and portray the tattooed person as a certain figure depending on the tattoos visible. There's a reason why employers don't allow multiple tattoos in the workplace. They don't want to hurt the appearance of the organization by allowing employees to expose their ink.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The author, Jonathan Halon, attempts to argue his perspective on the underlying issue of the stigma and associations of tattoos in today's world. It is clear that he feels that the consequences dealt out to those sporting visible tattoos are unfit given the times we live in as a part of the current generation. Another point made through the rhetoric of the underlying issue is the struggle for individuality.

    While, he makes interesting points, the author lacks the power of persuasion in his argument. The author is very biased, leaning, obviously, in favor of tattoos. His evidence is better than expected, and his personal experience adds perspective to the issue. Although this is true, an opposing opinion or conflicting evidence is missing from his essay, making it weak in part.

    I found his desire to exemplify the acceptance of diversity and the tolerance of today's society a bit expected or cliche. This being said, I did find his use of pop culture and historical examples effective in showing just exactly how our society has become more accepting.

    I, personally, have no problems with tattoos as long as they hold a specific meaning to its owner. I realize that it is hard to judge if a tattoo holds meaning or if that meaning is significant enough to be considered worthy of being permanently put on one's body in ink, but this is how I like to look at this issue. I will also admit that if my doctor had tattoos all over his or her visible skin, I would be a little curious and skeptical of his or her level of professionalism. But like many of my classmates, I believe it is more about the type and appearance of the tattoo more so than the fact that he or she has tattoos.

    Lastly, I would like to point out the interesting point Rich brought up earlier on in the blog post comments: "Based on this I believe that the author’s argument of whether or not it’s fair for your appearance to be a factor in acquiring a job to be irrelevant, because based on his experience appearance it is a qualifying factor for getting a job. Does anybody agree or disagree" (Rich)? Honestly, I did not even think of that the first time I read the essay, but your comment made me re-read the essay and really think about the author's personal experience. After analyzing the essay in your context, I completely agree. His argument is irrelevant given that he knew the stereotype of tattoos in the eyes of potential employers. He knew what was expected of his appearance, and therefore his essay is put under a different light, making it obvious that his essay was more of an emotional rant. Commonplace became the harbor in which he could release his personal disappointment in himself for ruining his chances at being seen as a professional in the workplace.

    ReplyDelete
  17. The underlying issue in this article is the issue of tattoos and how they are perceived in a professional manner. The bulk of this argument is based on prejudice and reactions towards tattoos. Mentioning tattoos and celebrities that have tattoos is relevant to the author's point of view because it backs up his evidence that many different people from different situations have them. The author makes significant arguments, yet the information is sometimes "fluffier", such as using celebrities as support. He does not quote from information or facts which makes it seem as though his information is more opinion-based.

    Personally, I believe that tattoos are an expression of creativity. You are free to do with your body what you want since it solely belongs to you. However I can be prone to judging and health care professionals are people you are trusting with helping you keep your body healthy. It could cross my mind why are my nurses or doctors heavily tattooed (if they were)? But again, it is their right and I do not believe anyone should be restricted from job opportunities or things of a similar nature based on their choices to express themselves. That being said, inappropriate drawings or words can be taken into account for jobs or professional opportunities, and should be treated the same as someone saying inappropriate information in an interview/professional setting.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I agree with Alaina's comment that some people get tattoos irrationally. When someone does this, it can make them appear less professional, especially if the tattoo is not significant or lacks importance to a person's self. This entire argument also makes me think of people with many piercings, and brings home the issue that appearance makes more of an impact than we sometimes realize or expect it to.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I agree with Jared when he says that today's society is changing and tattoos are becoming more accepted by the general public. However, a tattoo may have a very personal meaning to the owner, but an employer has no significant connection to the tattoo and therefore is more prone to pass judgement on someone before they hear what the tattoo is for. In business first impressions are everything, and sadly tattoos are still frowned upon in the majority of businesses today.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Throughout the article, the author is explaining his frustration with the older generation not accepting tattoos and how people perceive this type of art. He goes through explaining how he was denied a job, celebrities that have tattoos, and even how the Marines won't accept people with "sleeves". I feel the celebrity argument is very far fetched because they can do whatever they want with their bodies because if they are in a movie they can cover it up and most athletes and musicians have tattoos, so that has become kind of the norm. That part of the argument seemed very weak for me.

    Personally, I do not have a problem with tattoos, but if my doctor had various visible tattoos it would be hard not to second guess him but overall he would have gone to school for 8 years and these tattoos have no reflection on his personal ability. I also believe that people need to start thinking about their tattoos before they get them. Like the author, many people know that some if their tattoos are very visible and can hinder them from getting a job. If people were smarter about their tattoos and more cautious with their placement then I believe there would be no problem.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I agree with Kalon's comment when he said that employers have no significant connection to the employee's tattoos. Despite the fact that the general public is more accepting of tattoos, tattoos are still associated with negative things such as bikers, gangs, and defiant youth. It is best to just cover up tattoos than to show them off when applying for a job or when working in a professional setting.

    ReplyDelete
  22. now a days in our world appearance does mean everything. The way you present your self is looked at alot. The author tells ho he knows tattoos are frowned up so how than can you be surprised when they don't want you to work a their company because of your image. The author referring to other famous people who have tattoos is kind of relevant because their still able to stay in their jobs and have multiple tattoos. I wouldn't mind having a doctor or someone with multiple tattoos as long as they know what their doing.

    So i agree with Zack by don't judge someone because of the tattoos on their body because they can be the best at that profession but your judging them based on their image.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I think the author emphasizes that people in today still have negative emotion for tattoo which is meaningful or symbol of oneself. The author writes that “it is a form of art, a form of expression, not a cry of attention and criminal activity”. He argues that tattoos can be express interests and personality so people do not have to have always negative mind for tattoos. Also, he shows that tattoos are being very famous around us. He says “At least 36 percent of Americans aged 18 to 29 have at least one tattoo. In this article, the readers can realize that population of tattoos is increasing so it is becoming negative mind to positive. I think the author is well argued on this article because he shows not only his strong opinion but his observation. If my health professional have tattoos, I would feel comfortable because nowadays, I see too many people already have tattoos on their body. Even my current dentist has tattoos on his hands and neck. Now, I think it is time to get rid of stereotypes for tattoos.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.