Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Group 2, Post 2

It's Our Illegal Right
Consider this article from CommonPlace:



How does the article persuade you one way or another to illegally download or not illegally download music?
What makes this issue controversial?
How do you feel about Pembe's question: who is it really hurting?

23 comments:

  1. I for the most part completely agree with Pembe, but not for the same reasons. I download my music because I like A LOT of music and the bands that I listen to do not make a lot of money from record sales in the first place. I do make a solid effort to see as many of them live as I can and I always buy a new band's first album. The amount of money I would have spent getting my music is ludicrously high and I feel that since most of the money never actually reaches the band I like, then why bother? I also download because then when I do not like a band I haven't spent any hard earned cash on the album. The issue is controversial only because record companies make most of the profit while telling bands what they should sound like. There is a massive amount of bands that are now going independent of record companies because with that decision they make nearly all the profit and can produce whatever kind of music they desire. I was recently at a concert to see the band A Day To Remember and when they asked how many people bought the album and how many people downloaded it illegally nearly all the hands went up for illegal download. The band then said they didn't care because we paid to come see them play live. They just want to play music for their fans. The only thing that gets hurt from illegal downloading is record companies. Because for the most part they make all the money.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This article doesn't quite hit the mark for me. One of her claims seems a bit empty when you think about it. It's true that computers come with hardware to burn and rip music, but in actuality, are MOST people really burning and ripping music in large quantities? I may rip a cd and burn a copy for a few friends or my family, but I'm not producing 100s upon 100s of cds. Illegal downloading sites are promoting mass sharing of music for thousands of people. Illegal downloading sites, in this instance, are more detrimental to the music industry than individual burning and ripping on a computer. I'm not saying that I don't have issues with the recording industry, but I am saying that this essay's reasoning is a bit faulty.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Not to mention "theft of creativity". By illegally downloading a band's album and stripping them of the little money that they could be making off of you buying it from itunes, you are taking their songs with which they invested their time and emotions into in order to create them, and literally making that song worth nothing. Any band or artist that makes a song ought to receive something from their fans.. if they are true fans.. agree or disagree?

    ReplyDelete
  4. In some instances I do agree with you Jared, but in some instances I do not. I do believe a band should be rewarded for their efforts. If a group of people is putting their time and effort into something they consider their job then they should definitely be rewarded monetarily for their hard effort. Then again, I feel like small bands might want to have their songs downloaded illegally at first. It's so hard to be noticed in music these days. If a song first grew popular through illegally downloaded music, then it could make major profit when people actually start to buy it. It is just that starting point that bands need to make it big and I believe that is through illegal downloads. I feel as though small bands, at first, should want to be downloaded illegally.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree completely with Pembe. Due to Apple's Itunes completely monopolizing the music buying market now, most of what you pay for a song does not in fact go towards the artist, with whom complaints are saying "aren't getting paid" for their songs. Another point i think they fail to mention is concert sales for the artist. This is a huge part of an artists income and regardless of how their itunes sales are going, if an artist is good, people will pay money to see them. I find that the only people this is truly hurting is itunes due to the fact that if we are allowed to download for free, they no longer have a market for young people which is the majority of their sales. And i disagree with Jared only based on the fact that all upcoming bands make their songs, generally, for the simple reason that they enjoy music. Not every person is thinking while making a song "ok this is going to make millions". Basically saying to be a fan of us, you have to pay for our stuff, says volumes about what kind of band they really are and chances are, you are less likely to follow them at all if that is their mentality

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree that music today cost a lot of money, and if you can get it for free it’s pretty convenient. I personally do not like the idea of paying for music I can download off the internet for free. I also do not feel any sympathy for record companies or music artist, because there are ways from keeping you music from being “stolen” or leaked. Such as putting it on copy protected disk like they do movies, or just strictly doing live shows. Although my solutions may be bad ideas, the topic of illegally downloading music is so old and worn out it’s sad.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I personally like the idea of downloading music for free and Pembe makes some good points. Record companies should split the cost evenly with the artist because it was the artists music to begin with, but even so the internet has various ways of sharing these files and just like limewire it will take years for these online sharing companies who even make money from the impatient "consumers" to be brought to justice. Although companies like itunes and zune give credit to each artist and purchase it legally it seems with so many online file sharing websites available their efforts are in a sense cute but none the less almost pointless. Yes the government can catch you, if they take the time and money to investigate and find your ip address etc etc.... but doing that for every person that illegally downloads would take billions of dollars. Because artists can make money in other ways than just selling their songs it makes sense for it to be legal to download music for free.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I agree with Pembe completely for the fact that most of the artists are not even getting the full profit and like Ben said, the music sharing companies like Apple's iTunes are losing money. Most artists and bands don't go into the music making business with the thought of originally making millions. They start making music generally for the purpose of spreading their message or showing people they can produce good music. This issue is so controversial because in reality the people losing money are mainly the record companies rather than the artists, because as Pembe mentions, artists have endorsement deals and make a lot more money from that than music. Also, like stated above artists make a profit from doing tours, which is only done if they are liked which doesn't happen if they are restricted on what music they produce. For example, popular artist's music that is sold on iTunes has become very dance party like to appeal to the masses because that’s what sells but it isn't necessarily what the artists want. Therefore, the people hurting from this issue are the record companies and sales companies, while the artist's music quality is bettering.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I agree with Ben that the people are hurting is the sales companies like iTunes. Additionally, in my personal opinion artist's mixtapes generally are better than the albums sold on itunes, mainly because there is not record company telling the artist what to produce. Mixtapes are free and can be legally downloaded online and tend to be more meaningful to the listner and artist because it is made independently from the record comapny.

    ReplyDelete
  11. My stance on this is different that everyone else's in that my solution to expensive music is to not buy it at all. I do not listen to music often and when I do it usually is because the radio was already turned on when I turned on the car or walked into a room. If you were to look at my iPhone right now, you would see that I currently have 24 songs on it, all of which I bought from iTunes. So the article did not persuade me one way or the other. Because I rarely download music, when I do, I feel that I can afford the one dollar or so. It's clear to me that this can be controversial to people that do listen to music in that they want it cheap, or free, but in has consequences. No matter which way you download music, legally or illegally, someone has to pay for it. The difference is if you pay for it or if you make the artist and production company pay for it. Illegally downloading music just hurts everyone involved, which is why I tend to just avoid the whole situation.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I suppose Pembe did come up with a good issue,but really gave unacceptable and unconvincing reasons.
    I believe there are two basic facts.The first one is the contribution and work of artists and record companies should be awarded.The intellectual property rights should be protected,in this case,by downloading legally.The other one is , we college students indeed somehow don't have enough money,it is always painful to purchase something.However, I need to point out there is ,by any means,no logical relation between these two facts.It sounds ridiculous to me(I mean no offense),that we are obliged to download music illegally just for the reason we are somehow poor!No to mention the saying,college students should take the advantage of being smart to download illegally and efficiently.It stands for no point.We are not educated to do wrong(or illegal techniquely speaking) things.What's difference between being educated to make drugs with this.Perhaps only the degree of misconduct differs.
    In my opinion,everyone is hurting.People complain having difficulty accessing to music.While artists and record companies suffer from benefit loss.Neither side wins in this case unless it reaches a balanced point.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This article does not persuade me one way or the other because it actually agrees with my point of view. With that said, I don't know if this article would persuade me to follow the authors point of view if I did not agree with him/her. It almost sounds like an exact speech I have given my mom when she warned me that music downloading is illegal. I feel like the points are not very strong and are not backed up by any solid evidence. I understand what makes the issue so controversial - it is theft plain and simple, but it is also extremely easy to do and very rarely enforced. It is almost more of a moral issue than a legal one, the person downloading the music must make the decision for themselves. As far as the question of "who is it really hurting?" I think the answer is obvious. It is hurting anybody that profits from the sale of records or singles. This is an issue I look forward to following in the future to see if it becomes more strictly enforced.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I find it hard to differ from anybody because it seems we all have the same basic idea. We all believe that it is not the worst thing to pirate music online. I do really like a small point that Jacob made though. He talked about artists starting out trying to spread their message and show their talent. I think this is what their aim should be throughout their whole career. We all know what happens when they lose sight of this and start getting greedy for money, they "sell out". If not paying for music can prevent this then I am definitely all for it.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I would like to preface by saying this: I have partaken in illegally downloading music due to monetary constraints, and I will most likely continue to do it in the future for the same reason. With this being said, I think it is rather ironic that the author's point of view has actually persuaded me somewhat against downloading music illegally. This is mainly due to the fact that I feel as though it is rather insensitive to say "who is this really hurting?". Although I feel as though it is not necessarily vital to the functioning of society, music is still in fact an industry that benefits from making a profit. So to answer two questions in one, making music free to college students hurts the music industry by depriving it of money and the musicians who attempt to make a living by making music. As I have said earlier, I will most likely continue to download music illegally, but I do not believe that such actions should be allowed. I would rather live with the guilt than see an entire industry be disrespected.

    As the author states, this is a rather controversial issue due to the ease of ability to download and mass produce illegally. Because there are many laws in place protecting such an ability, this becomes a large legal dilemma.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Much like Peter, I do not share the same experience or opinion regarding illegal downloading. I have never illegally downloaded music from any sites. I always either buy the album/songs legally or not at all. There are laws for a reason, and I will not be one to break them.
    Another reason why I do not partake in illegal downloading is because I feel it does disrespect the artist. While, it is a good point that the record companies get more of the profit than the artist, I still do not feel that I can morally disobey a law. For this reason, this issue is controversial for me. If there was not a law against, this issue would not get nearly any attention, given that there would be no dispute over whether or not it should be done.
    While this article did not convince me to start downloading music illegally, it brought up some very goods points. That being said, its biggest selling point was its argument of how downloading music for free could affect the financial hardships of a college student.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I personally have illegally downloaded music and I have for years now. All of my friends even download music illegally just because it is so much easier and music is so expensive to buy now. After reading this article, I will still continue to download illegally. Sometimes I feel bad about illegal downloading, but I feel as if the artists aren't the ones that are being hurt due to the fact that some artists are now giving away their albums for free. This issue is controversial because it can be seen everywhere. Almost everyone I know downloads illegally and there is just no way that they can enforce laws on everyone that illegally downloads because there is just way too many. Now I do believe some people get out of hand with the downloading by downloading 100s of songs at a time, but I feel that it's not as big of a deal to download 20-25 songs. Overall, I feel like this hurting all of the record companies more than anyone. As everyone has said, artists can make money in so many different ways that this doesn't hurt them as much, and they aren't the ones gaining the most money from the music sales.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I agree with Pembe. I like the fact that music online is free because it does cost more to buy the cds and what if their not good and you paid for the album. If artists don't want their music to be put on the free music download sites than lose money they should be their music on copy protected disks.

    I agree with Phil having free music available to a college student is going to make you download free song so i will continue to download music. Who is this really hurting is the music companies and the artists whose songs are being downloaded for free while they lose their profits.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I agree with Phil and Dezoray that if free music is available to download then I will download it. Being a college student that has to pay for school I am not going to "waste" my money buying an artist's cd when I can get it for free online. I have more important things to spend my money on.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I have always downloaded music in any way I can to get the tracks I want. Sometimes it's best to buy it the legal way, especially if it isn't mainstream music. But music that is more underground or is instrumental I find is just easier to download legally because it is easier to find that way. This article hasn't changed my mind one bit about how I go about getting my music. It has, however, opened my mind to a lot of things I never thought of before. It almost makes me feel less guilty for getting music illegally. This issue is controversial because getting music off of Frostwire or BitTorrent is illegal yet the article is almost telling you that you might as well get the music for free. I feel that by doing so, it is only hurting the greedy record companies, who are making money in a very easy way, by exploiting the talents of artists who just want to perform.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I completly agree with what Melissa and Eric said. This article hasn't persuaded me in the slightest nor has it made me contemplate the way I think about this topic. Its argument aren't anything that I haven't seen before and its reasoning is backed up by vague facts that anyone could have made up by simple logic. It sounds like it could possibly be correct, but where are the solid facts? Some numbers or something would make this artile seem a little more reliable.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I strongly agree that the music album should be illegally download because if it not illegally, many of controversial issues would be cause around the world. For example, think about people who sell music album and singer who is not as much of famous as Rihanna. First of all, nowadays, sales of musical recording are the worst the industry because too many people illegally download so sellers of musical recording are getting hard time and loss their income. Obviously, I do illegally download but sellers of the music album still exist. Secondly, there are few stars incredibly rich for example Rihanna but there are many normal singers more than famous singers. Normal singers might wish people just listen their music through illegally download because they usually effort on making their song in order to get spread around the world and be more famous. The author does not well describe the persuasive question. The question, “who is it really hurting?” is not really touch my heart. When I read this question, I think deeply not only sellers of musical recording but also normal singers.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I completely agree with Phil about this illegal music thing. While the article didn't really do anything to my mind, I've always felt that little bit of guilt about stealing stuff from the internet. This normally actually leads me to buy things which I really have no reason to buy. I'll get multiple copies of an album which I already have, and if I like a game or movie I've stolen enough I feel it's only right to purchase it in order to give the producers the money they deserve even if it isn't too much. I think piracy is really nothing but good for artists though. It only takes money from sales of people who wouldn't have spent anything for it anyway, so it is spreading the music to a new audience.

    Many of the classmate's reasoning of not bothering to spend money when an artist doesn't get much sounds completely hypocritcal. If the music is from an artist who doesn't get much of the money from sales, that just means that they need the sale money more. Sure, you may not be helping out the (maybe) oppressive record label, but you are monetarily hurting the artist.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.