Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Group #1: Post #2

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/washington/2011/06/michele-bachmann-confuses-john-wayne-gacy-with-the-duke.html

Everyone! Read this article from the LA Times, and also watch the youtube video attached! The questions posed are:
1) How does this portray Michele Bachman or how does her "screw-up" affect her political image?
2) What makes this controversial?
3) How does the following article affect your thoughts or opinion of this subject?


12 comments:

  1. Although this news piece attempts to refrain from bias in its writing, it is apparent that it the goal of this piece is political slander. Not only does the piece focus on Bachman's most recent blunder, it also begins with an exposition describing the other blunders leading up to it. In this example, the author does not explicitly ridicule Bachman, but rather chose a specific piece of recent news to paint the picture of someone who is rude and too immature to publicly accept an apology. His rhetoric points towards this as well, saying that she "did not find it necessary" to apologize to the veteran, and neglected "one small detail" with John Wayne. The author also posted a link to an archive of Bachman's other blunders.

    This piece of news is controversial because there is a large difference between John Wayne and John Wayne Gacy. One is considered a hero, while the other is a serial killer. This stipulation is only amplified by the fact that Bachman neglected to do the research to realize that the John Wayne she wanted to address is relevant, while the serial killer could be considered relevant to her statement.

    This article only affects my opinion of Michele Bachman because it demonstrates that she continues to prove her incompetence in front of a large public audience. I never liked her as a politician, and this article only helps to amplify this feeling.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Michele Bachmann's confusion over where John Wayne is from affects her political image negatively. This news is so controversial because she screwed up John Wayne with John Wayne Gacy, the mass murderer. Therefore, her statement "Well what I want them to know is just like John Wayne was from Waterloo, Iowa. That's the kind of spirit that I have, too." makes her come across as a political mass murderer. Voters will now not think twice when considering her at the polls due to this screw up.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The article portrays a negative image on Bachman and almost says that she has the spirit of a serial killer. The article is obviously bias, because it slanders Bachman even though she did mix up two very different people, making it very controversial. The fact that she got a American known hero and an American known serial killer shows that Bachman doesn’t know her facts which shows voters that she isn’t a good fit for the white house. Moreover, the writer says, “add this to the growing list of gaffes,” showing that writer doesn’t necessarily like Bachman, therefore making it seem like Bachman is much worse than she is. On the other hand, mixing up two very different things and referring yourself to an infamous criminal is not smart and not something that should be said on national news. This article makes my opinion of Bachman worsen. I was never a fan but this article is an example of how she is not right for the presidency.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with Alaina in that this reflects negatively on her politically. A mistake such as this is costly and can seriously effect the result of an election. She made one mistake and that would hopefully result in her being more careful when making these type of comments about people. She is prone to making mistakes, however, and it is a risk that voters may look down upon.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with what Jacob said. This type of slip up not only shows she is not a good candidate but also links her with a known mass murderer, which is not good when she is trying to get the vote of the American people. this article does prove to be bias and you can see that the writer is not a fan of Bachman. This article shows how one slip up can really mess you up and it shows her weaknesses and how she is not right for the presidency.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I don’t believe Michele’s “screw-up” will affect her in the slightest. The media is always looking for stories, and she just happened to slip up and give them one. I hate when dumb things like this get blown out of proportion, and I hate it even more when people who don’t even follow politics try to discredit a potential candidate for any position based on stupid things like this. I mean how many people in this class knew anything SIGNIFIGANT about Michele before this post. I also believe that even if she got her comparison right, people would still be appalled at her comparing herself to “The Duke” John Wayne. Who if I am not mistaken killed more people than he brought to justice in 95% his movies, regardless of if they were outlaws or not. Real heroes don’t need bullets. Real heroes are the people who try to change the world by breaking barriers, like Michele is trying to do by becoming the first woman president. Now you tell me who the real hero is.

    ReplyDelete
  7. While I am in complete agreement with not having Michele Bachman in the white house, I found this article to be very overly biased towards how bad of a candidate she is in general, and didn't put very much focus on this specific mistake. This act of stupidity from the candidate may be a common occurrence, but I don't feel that it's the job of the media to blatantly write towards their own biases. What makes this article controversial to me is not the confusion between a cowboy and a clown, (which I really think is actually a fairly understandable mistake compared to her others) but the fact that instead of getting reliable facts from the news we are getting biased persuasive journalism.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This article makes Bachmann look like an idiot who seems to think comparing herself to a serial murderer is a good thing, even though she didn't mean to make that particular comparison. The article is quite biased against Bachmann and portrays her as arrogant and confused. It mentions how her "confidence was so mighty" that she didn't accept an apology from someone, which portrays her negatively (as arrogant), while not even talking about the subject of the article itself. It's controversial because she essentially made it seem like she was talking about a murderer, not a famous cowboy star. I agree with Richard that these kinds of things are usually stupid and tend to get blown out proportion, but I'd have to disagree that Michele Bachmann is some kind of hero. This is not the first time she has said something utterly stupid. She once said that the Lion King supported gay marriage and that it was a bad influence on kids, simply because the soundtrack was written by Elton John, who happens to be gay. This is unbelievably dumb logic, in my opinion, and I would never want to see her be the first female president. Considering this along with the many other dumb things she has said, this article really only reaffirms my opinion of her.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Well,I have to say the "screw-up" is pretty OK with me, I don't see any points that this accident will affect a lot for Michele Bachman to continue her candidacy for president.I mean, in terms of electing president, it is always competitive. During this kind of sensitive period of time , people especially political figures easily catch attention of the media and then of the public. In some way , I suppose the media,both the press and the TV station tend to function improperly by leading the public opinion sometimes into wrong directions. The common act media take in these cases is to exaggerate the facts and amplify points which don't or rarely make sense.In extreme cases, even distinguishing media like Fox would act like paparazzi seek for celebrities' gossips, like in this case. People make mistakes and surely we need to reason why they make mistakes but only in a rational way. I suppose Michele Bachman definitely wanted to show her courage and strength the voters when mentioning John Wayne and we definitely know she refers to John Wayne the cowboy but not John Wayne the killer. What's the point to focus on the trivial.In deed, by making such mistake, Michele Bachman show she (and her team)didn't do enough research. But just as I said ,people make mistakes and other candidates make similar mistakes too. It shouldn't be the proof that she and other candidates are not that qualified for these are trivial things and viewers have to be rational and use their own brain to think. It is the way the media act that annoyed me, they did catch eyes but showed their irresponsibility for the audience and public opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Remember everyone, we aren't looking at Bachman and accessing whether or not she is a good candidate, we are analyzing an article ABOUT her in order to access how the author is framing their argument for or against her. Keep this in mind as you approach other topics on the blog.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.