Monday, November 14, 2011

Group 6 Post 1

When responding to this blog post keep in mind these two things:
1. We are looking for an analysis of the articles rhetoric and how they are written. We do not want to hear your opinion of Penn State and the scandal.
2. Melissa went to Penn State

Read these two articles from the Ohio State newspaper and Penn State newspaper:
OSU
PSU

What were your initial reactions to the articles?

How did the tone and wording of each article influence you as a reader?

How are the arguments presented through the use of stories, evidence, or other ways?

How do the biases differ between the articles?

Please post any final comments you might have about the two articles.

11 comments:

  1. My initial reaction to the OSU article is that it basically reported exactly what ESPN has been saying, it went with the facts and was not overly biased. My reaction to the PSU article is that it is very much a biased article and shows a lot of emotion which should not be the goal in journalism. I for one dislike almost all of the coverage this has been given because this entire thing hasn't gone to court. Though I believe that Sandusky did the acts he did, I can't help but wonder if all of this didn't actually happen. It's a big what if question, but considering all of the facts have yet to come out, most of the media given to this is just based off the testimonies given in the grand jury report. The object of Journalism is to stay objective. The OSU article actively charges Sandusky with the crimes without a trial, while the PSU article is just defending Joe Paterno and commenting that his firing was in the author's opinion, wrong. That said I really think that the media got Joe Paterno fired, for some reason ESPN decided that JoePa was the main reason that all this happened and focused many of their stories on him. Almost no time has been given to the graduate assistant that walked away from a man raping a child and then waited years to finally come forward.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ha! I wrote for The Collegian newspaper when I was an undergrad @ PSU.

    ReplyDelete
  3. and by the way, the second source is actually a letter to the editor and not an article...

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think that since the second source is a letter to the editor, the author has every right to be opinionative. Otherwise, I would have copletely agreed with Zach. As well, the media in general, including both of these articles have ephasis on different facts, or even conflicting facts all together. I think that the media has to get its story strait.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with Grace, in that the Media interpretative of the story is very skewed and varies from source to source. This is evident from these two articles. And as Grave and Zach both said, this is the main reason for Paterno's being fired, as the media is blowing Paterno's role in this out of proportion.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm going to completely agree with Zach on this one. The Lantern article gave the facts and kept the reader intrigued by giving more and more details as to what exactly was happening and what is going to happen as a result of the tragedy. In contrast, the PSU letter to the editor is pure emotion and pure bias. Someone who has loved JoePa his entire life and is absolutely PISSED at the Penn State University Officials. It is pure pathos and has not ethos to it. I also completely agree with what Zach said about the media getting JoePa fired. I believe this to be 100% true. We, as viewers, pay attention to what media tells us to pay attention to(Communications 200 reference). With all of the media attention on JoePa, the story escalated much quicker than it should have, which resulted in the quick decision to fire JoePa.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I also agree with the sentiments already discussed. The article remains unbiased and factual, while relaying Ohio State v. Penn State information at the bottom of the article to help relate OSU to PSU. The letter to the editor is very emotional, distraught, and heated. As a reader, I found that the PSU letter to the editor was very "in the moment" mad, but I can understand how this issue struck such a cord with this alumnae.

    ReplyDelete
  8. In my initial reaction, I was very shocked to see more of a disapproving tone from the letter than the article. I was surprised that there was not more bias within The Lantern article. While it is understandable for the letter to contain mainly pathos, I found by self thrown off when the alum of Penn State said the he was going to rid his life of all associations with being a PSU alumnus, and that his son would not be his legacy. I found that to be disloyal on his part. Otherwise, I agree with my classmates completely!

    ReplyDelete
  9. My initial reaction to both articles is that Penn State is in some pretty deep crud. I will let a bit of my personal opinion slip out here, but both of these articles evoked a feeling of sympathy for Joe Paterno. The tone of the Lantern article was very factual, definitely not much bias. The tone of the letter to the editor in the PSU paper was obviously very distraught. The writer clearly shows biases towards Paterno and the program as a whole. I believe both articles are effective in their separate ways. The OSU article definitely showed me more that I did not know about the situation by using facts. The PSU article evoked a strong emotional reaction, even from someone like me with no connection to PSU. I think this was a really good idea for the blog and the two articles chosen were great in the fact that they were so different. Bravo.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I want to also kindly disagree with what Zach and Cody mentioned about the media getting Joe Paterno fired. The truth is as the "head" of the football program at PSU it was absolutely his responsibility to make sure something was done. Although I do understand that he went to his superior, he had plenty of time to realize that nothing was being done and to alert more people of the situation. PSU football is in for some serious reconstructing and I don't think its illogical for them to start at the top.

    ReplyDelete
  11. My initial reaction toward the lantern article is the author did a good job remaining an objective tone This is a good report for I think the article explains clearly what happened and the background information of it without mixing personal preference and judgement. Actually, I wouldn't know this article comes from our university paper until I read the last paragraph.
    However, the other article or letter is much more emotional. The author supports the former coach by saying"Joe Paterno committed no crime","Joe Paterno’s role in the terrible Sandusky scandal was peripheral at best." On the other hand, the author harshly accused Penn State administrative with "needlessly tie this scandal to our beloved JoePa.".He even goes with "I am no longer a Penn Stater".
    The objective tone used in the first source will lead audience to get to know about the incident, while the other one will probably cause argument and debate. Audience will at least separate into to groups, one supports the author while the other doesn't.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.