Monday, November 14, 2011

Group 6 Post #2

Please answer the following questions with an emphasis on how the advertisements are constructed and what do they hope to accomplish in the commercial
Modern Warfare 3
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eLjgRmJUwpU
Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TEj7GfQT7Z8

1. What game appealed more to you based off of the commercials?
2. What kind of tone is present in each commercial?
3. Which seems more inclusive to a wider audience? What range of audience does each seem to be targeting?
4. How is the use of a realistic city setting affect the audience's opinion of these games?
5. Any other comments you would like to make about the commercials

17 comments:

  1. I find that neither game truely appeals to me, however if I had to pick I would choose the Legend of Zelda commercial, because it focuses on the main aspects of the gameplay and the ability to have a lot of control over the sword. The MW3 commercial is focused on trying to be funny and show that even someone like Jonah Hill can become good at the game. The Zelda game is set on showing the audience the new features and challenges of the game. The MW3 is targeting everyone while the Zelda game is targeting mostly fans of the series and trying to attract new comers. The use of a realistic setting doesn't really have an effect on me. Especially in the MW3 commercial because the entire thing is so unrealistic the fact that they didn't just show gameplay boggles my mind. The Zelda setting really didn't affect me at all because it quickly showed gameplay of the game. Overall game commercials will never really make me want to buy a game, reading up on what they are doing differently and how they are improving the game or series will make me buy it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Modern Warfare 3 appeals more to me based off of the two commercials. Within that commercial, the company uses a comical tone to attract the audience in and to get the point across that the "noob" can eventually become the "vet". The Zelda commercial uses a tone that challenges the audience, asks them if they had what it takes to yield the sword. It seems as though the MW3 commercial is more inclusive to a wider audience because at the end of the trailer it says, "There's a soldier in all of us", which to me it seems that that means everyone. Everyone has the ability to play the game and become a "soldier". The MW3 commercial seems to target everyone, while the Zelda commercial seems to target fans of the franchise. I don't think the setting of each commercial has an impact on the way the audience looks at these games. Although I do think it's interesting that the MW3 commercial doesn't show any gameplay.

    I agree with the comment that Zach said about what makes him buy video games, I am the same way, a commercial doesn't make me want to flat out buy or not buy a game. I have been a fan of the Call of Duty series for a long time and I actually have MW3 in the disk drive on the PS3 in my dorm. So far the game is really good, and from playing online with other people across the world I can see some similarities between the game I am playing and the commercial. I can see people who just started playing, not quite aware of how the game works or what to do, and I also see people who have played this game before and are "veterans" of the franchise.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword appealed to me more but that could possibly just be because I have been looking forward to it's release for forever! I felt the MW3 commercial was long, drawn out and completely unrealistic. The Zelda commercial was short and to the point. It didn't show anyone famous becoming Link and fighting off enemies or anything like that. Plus the Zelda commercial was music that builds and gives you the feeling of anticipating something spectacular (like the game). MW3 commercial makes me feel like it is a new comical action movie coming to theaters instead of a video game. I didn't like the fact that there is no showing of any gameplay. I think they both are pretty inclusive to a wide audience. The MW3 commercial is trying to say anyone can be a soldier in Call of Duty and the Zelda commercial is challenging all to "carry the sword". I think the use of a real city is trying to show how you can really become a part of the game or more the game can become a part of your real world. I like how in the Zelda commercial the sword falls from the sky. It brings the game into the real world where MW3 doesn't transition the game into the real world. That being said these commercials alone don't make me want to buy the game. I will buy Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword because well I am already a huge Zelda fan.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The Modern Warfare 3 commercial appealed to me more mostly because it seemed more realistic. The Zelda commercial definately focused on the idea that it is a fantasy game coming into reality, which is hard to believe. On the other hand, the MW3 commercial is unlikely, but still possiblle in reality.
    I think that the MW3 could have a wider based audience. One thing that stuck out to me that would support this is the phrase at the end of the commercial that stated, "There's a soldier in all of us". This suggests that the game is for everyone and anyone. However, the Zelda commercial had a phrase that stated, "Do you have the power to weild the sword?". This suggests that only a select few will succeed in the game.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Based of the commercial and due to the fact that I love MW3, I would say the MW3 commercial worked better for me. The tone in the Zelda commercial takes a more serious tone by basically asking whether or not you are capable of wielding "the sword". However Call of Duty's commercial takes a humorous approach with their tone by saying there's a soldier in all of us, you just need to find it. MW3 is more inclusive based on what I said above about how they clearly state "there's a soldier in all of us". The Zelda commercial seems to focus more on teens who
    are fantasy type gamers. I believe that the use of the city environment makes these commercials more realistic in a sense of the word. Being that warfare these days does take place in some urban environments makes the MW3 commercial more realistic however than commercial where swords and shields are falling from the sky onto peoples cars and into their homes. I agree with some of the points Zach is making but I have to point out that unlike him, I base my purchase of video Games purely by the commercials that the companies put on the market.

    ReplyDelete
  6. From the two commercials, I would have to say that the MW3 commercial was more appealing to me as well, and this is coming from someone who dislikes CoD and has played pretty much every single Zelda game to date and loved each one. The MW3 commercial works better for one simple reason: it was much louder and more fast-paced than the Skyward Sword commercial, which caught my attention much quicker.

    As stated above, the MW3 commercial had a much more fast-paced, comic tone to it, whereas Skyward Sword was rather calm and serious. This would imply, perhaps, that MW3 is attempting to target people who want excitement in their lives and want to play with other people, even from around the world (as implied by the many different places they explore). The Zelda commercial, on the other hand, shows imagery of living rooms and is overall a darker setting, implying that a "calmer" person who enjoys playing single-player video games would be much more interested in that.

    Most people who have some knowledge of video games understand that the CoD series attempts to reach a wider audience, and this is evident from the celebrity cameos. Both of the videos attempt to advertise their product to young males, most likely between the ages of 18-25, as seen by the fact that everyone in the commercials is a young male.

    While the imagery and setting of each commercial is different, both commercials use the realistic city in order to bring their representative game into real life, and show that real people can experience what is in the game if they buy it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Out of both commercials the MW3 commercial is more appealing to me because it was more fast paced and used comedy to appeal to the audience. On the other side, the Zelda game was more serious and didn't make sense to me until the end of the commercial. The MW3 commercial was also very action-packed making it more exciting and drawing in the viewer quicker and easier than the calm and more simple Zelda commercial.

    The MW3 game seemed to appeal to a wider audience because it implied that even though you may not be good at the game with practice you can become a veteran and be great at the game. To add, the commercial ends with, "There's a soldier in all of us," pointing out that anyone can play this game. The Zelda game however, appeals to mainly young men because the people wielding the swords are young men. To add, people that don't play Zelda may not know what is being advertised until the end when the game is being played.

    The use of both commercials being filmed in realistic cities tries to make the games both seem more realsitic and appeal to a wider audience. Also, putting them in a real city can also be used to make the game seem more global and widespread because it is being played everywhere. Yet, the use of a realistic city scene is better shown in the MW3 commercial because more i being done in the city and the game actually take place in the modern day world while Zelda is set in a fantasy world.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with Jacob that the use of comedy makes the MW3 commercial more appealing, especially since they used the Dwight Howard cameo. I also feel that the commercials have similar tones seeing as they both seem to be geared at putting players in the game, but MW3’s commercial probably had more money put into its production, which made it an overall better commercial. The Zelda commercial targets a wide range of people which is apparent by the swords and shields raining down all over the place, while the MW3 commercial is geared towards “noobs”. I believe the use of realistic cities make these commercials appeal to the everyday person, which is always a great strategy when it comes to marketing.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I disagree with Phil. I think the MW3 commercial was long and drawn out compared to the Legend of Zelda commercial. It took MW3 a minute and 30 seconds to sell their commercial compared to the 30 seconds of the Zelda commercial. I was bored with the MW3 commercial by the time it was over even though it had a couple funny parts.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The MW3 commercial appealed to me more because it had good action, some comedy, and was fast-paced. With these characteristics, the video is showing the fast-paced, action-packed game play that takes place in the game, which helps appeal to the audience of gamers who like these types of games.

    The video also appeals to a wider audience by using comedy and the actor, Jonah Hill. Jonah Hill is known by a wide variety of people for the comedic movies he has been in, which draws people into the commercial and makes them watch the entire thing. The video then also says "There is a soldier in all of us" telling the viewer that anyone can play this game, especially with a little practice.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I agree with Cody that the use of Jonah Hill and his connotation for being a funny actor adds to the commercial. Moreover, I think the use of Sam Worthington who is a semi-well known action star adds to the commercial by making it more action packed and makes the game seem more action packed but still fun for all ages.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Personally, the MW3 worked better for me. Although I really don't play either of these video games I enjoyed watching the MW3 commercial better. The MW3 commercial has a comical tone, which works for me, and the Zelda commercial has a more serious tone. I feel the MW3 commercial appealed to a wider audience showing how the noob can become the vet and showing how anyone can play. The MW3 commercial is appealing to audience of basically anyone by saying, "There's a soldier in all of us" while the Zelda commercial is appealing to people who have played Zelda before and like fantasy games. By showing these commercials taking place in a realistic city setting, it shows that these commercials can be real. I feel like the MW3 commercial is more realistic because warfare does take place sometimes in the city, but the Zelda commercial is not realistic by having swords falling from the sky, which will probably never happen.

    I agree with what Rich says and I feel he brought up a good point about the Dwight Howard cameo that hadn't been mentioned yet. It is at the very end of the commercial and I think it might be overlooked. I also agree that MW3 probably had more money put into it's production since the CoD series is one of the most successful and profitable series ever. This is an important thing to consider when looking at these commercials because if you have more money you should be able to make a better commercial.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Based on the commercial content, Zelda appeared more to me. It was quick, and effective! The Zelda commercial's tone is serious and intense, trying to communicate the challenge of the game. The MW3's tone is humorous and played off like a movie trailer, however it drags on making it feel like a movie that doesn't have much content (even though it is for a game, if it was shorter, it would be more effective. The MW3 seem to appeal to a wider audience using famous celebrities to make it relatable - it is available for anyone willing whereas the Zelda seems to be challenging only people "worthy of the sword", however it also appeals to a more youthful audience. The city makes ever user relate to the "real world", it takes a virtual game and intermingles it with our actual lives.
    Overall, the commercials work well, but don't make me need to go out and play the video games.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Though I would never play either of these games, the commercial for Modern Warfare 3 is more appealing. It's use of crude humor and celebrities makes it more memorable and intriguing to try. On the other hand, if I played video games frequently, I may have a different opinion.

    In the first commercial, the tone is extremely humorous. Using Jonah Hill implies that the commercial has to be funny, similarly to what Cody said earlier. The second commercial takes on a more serious and mysterious vibe, sparking curiosity.

    I would say that both have a pretty wide range of audience, but Zelda would appeal more to people would already play Zelda.

    The use of a realistic city in the Modern Warfare 3 commercial makes it more humorous and crude in a way. It also is relatable to movies such as Transformers.

    ReplyDelete
  15. The commercial that stood out to me the most was the modern warfare 3 game because it seems more appealing. The zelda commercial shows the new features that the game has to offer. But the modern warfare game shows how they think everyone can play it and that everyone is "a solider". I think the modern warfare would a appeal to a greater audience.

    I agree with Liz that the modern warfare commercial is more appealing and memorable because its more humorous.

    ReplyDelete
  16. For me ,the first commercial sounds more appealing. I am a shooting game fan, the first ad perfectly reveals the grandness of battle filed. I get excited even watching the video.
    The first ad adapts a stirring tone. By presenting fight with your teammate in different regions using various weapons, the attraction to young guys is significant. While the other seems to introduce the potential players into a fantasy world, therefore the tone used in this commercial is more gender and romantic.
    The WW3 is definitely more inclusive to wilder audience. They feel blood pumping when given the feel of battling in the real world. However, the ad also targets the less wilder audience. In fact, the noob wasn't good at battle at first, but after getting through the war, he eventually stood out and "saved the world". This design will show the less wilder audience that they too can be part of the game and play well.
    Also, I find another interesting scene that Dwight Howard appears too. This adds to the attraction to sports fans like me.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Actually, first commercial attracted me more because I could feel reality more than second one. In the first commercial, I could see famous action movie description action parts which are Battle Royal, Mr. & Mrs. Smiths, Die Hard 3, Transformer and Mission Impossible. I think this commercial actually invests a lot of money in order to give more reality. Atmosphere of first commercial, they based on fasted serious action and busy to fight. It is very possible to keep engage. In the second commercial, Zelda, it seems to like targeting not only children but the adult who play that game when he was child. Zelda can appealed to like my ages. Because Zelda becomes in my generation. So, if the commercial were targeted in not only child but also my age, it has to be more concentrated at design. In this commercial, the sword was most influence and main object. But the design don’t have any reality.(It looks like Lego.)

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.