http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQTwtFUcGUg
In this commercial, Sophia Vergara advertises her new clothing line for women inviting them to "be proud, be sexy," and finally, to "dress like a woman." Based on the commercial, how would Sophia define being a woman? Based on her definition, how would a "woman" dress? Why does this commercial work? Or why doesn't this commercial work? How is it trying to appeal to its audience?
Note: Something else to consider would be the differences between this version of the commercial and other versions that are out there. If any of you have watched shows on mtv.com, you may have seen a version of this commercial. If you have, you may notice a difference in the positioning of Sophia's body by the final shot. This could be particularly interesting when you consider the audience for mtv.com vs. other network channels.
Sophia Vergara portrays "a woman" as someone who should dress sexy and trendy. It appeals to the general audience because most women would kill to look like her, and therefore believe that wearing her clothing line will helpt to acheive that. However, this is a blaintantly sexist comercial. It implies that women cannot be women unless they are beautiful according to society's ridiculusly high standards for women's appearences.
ReplyDeleteThis video is meant to illustrate what an attractive, sexy and confident woman should be. If you wear Sophia Vergara's clothing than you should be assumed a "woman". Her definition of a “woman” is beauty and sex appeal that is portrayed through clothing. But a woman is not a one-faceted creature; she can be herself in different ways. This clip aims at cultivating women as a hurdle of sexy ladies who wear Vergara's clothing line. Since it is an advertisement it is produced to allure buyers, it shows females of different ethnicities and shapes to appeal to a larger audience. Overall the message can be somewhat condescending; are women meant to be prideful through their bodies alone?
ReplyDeleteBased on the commercial, Sophia would define being a woman as being confident and proud of who you are. This commercial is intended to tell women that they should dress how they want to and embrace their body types. This commercial works, because it is not telling women how they should dress, but telling them they should have the confidence to dress how they want to. That being said, I cannot see any signs of sexism or hints of ideas that demean women in any way. K-Mart’s clientele is much broader than that of a Macys or Bloomingdales, so to sponsor a commercial or clothing line that hinted at those ideas would be idiotic on their part. Overall I consider the overall theme of the video to be empowering to women, and if you don’t like it. Then don’t buy Sophia’s clothes.
ReplyDeleteIn this commercial, Sophie Vergara is advertising trendy clothes by taking off her clothes and taking on various personalities of good looking women. In this fashion, She is suggesting that all women can have the chance to look good regardless of who they are. Sophie's good looks and desirable tone of voice are tools to convince female viewers to go to Kmart to buy those clothes. To Sophia, being a woman means looking outstanding regardless of social status or any other limits (hence the Kmart commercial). From my point of view, this commercial doesn't work because the average woman may not associate themselves with Sophie Vergara even if her clothes are sold at Kmart. On the flip side, a woman that wants to look like Sophie Vergara may buy her clothes, but the fact that they're sold at an average store like Kmart may turn away such buyers.
ReplyDeleteThe commercial encourages women to wear clothes that make them feel comfortable with themselves and to embrace their sexuality. Sophia tells her intended audience to dress like a woman, to be sexy and flaunt it. She conveys the message that every woman can be sexy if they dress the part, and that is where her clothing line comes into play. This commercial can either be a hit or miss when it comes to the audience. Many people can view this commercial as a way that may give them more confidence in themselves, while others may be completely turned off at the idea that in order to dress like a woman, that one has to purchase this clothing line. In conclusion, I believe that this commercial is intended to give women more confidence and to embrace their sexuality.
ReplyDeleteAs stated in the commercial,Sophia defines women are to "be proud and be sexy".According to this ad,it seems the appearance, the body and the clothing of women play a significant role in judging whether a women is successful ,I mean being in the way women should to be which is hard to give a certain criteria,in some way.As for my opinion ,this is definitely wrong,is it enough for women to look pretty or attractive,or is it necessary to be so?I bet not.However, since it is a commercial ad,it does not need to appeal to everyone.As long as there women who think of it appealing, this ad should work to attract these women to buy such clothing.Because this is just an ad,I suppose there is need to take it too seriously.However, I do think this commercial lacks some high-level things.
ReplyDeleteI support what Anna said."a woman is not a one-faceted creature; she can be herself in different ways",this is exactly what I suppose women meant to be nowadays.By illustrating so,this commercial may lose some possible buyers who believe women are by no means just as simple as having good body or good clothing.
ReplyDeleteThe main purpose of this commercial is to get people to buy Sophia's clothes. They say that women should be proud and sexy and that is exactly what Sophia is. She does a very good job at marketing her line because she is easy on the eyes, and by just seeing her in the commercial it will get people to buy her clothes. The commercial goes through phases of showing different women in the clothes, which is trying to show that any woman can be sexy and these clothes will help them do that. But my main problem with the commercial is that a woman does not need certain clothes to make herself feel proud and sexy. All she needs is to wear what makes her comfortable.
ReplyDeleteCameron brings up a very valid point. Because Sophia is easy on the eyes, this advertisement has a potential to influence many female viewers. I believe as well that this advertisement is successful in marketing clothing towards women, but only to the extent that other women let the insecurity of "dressing like a woman" have a hold on them. Pride and blind following are two completely separate concepts.
ReplyDeleteThe message of this commercial is saying that woman should show off what they have and that is what Richard wrote. On the other hand, Nick brings up a good point that this commercial may be seen as a "hit or miss" because women may think that in order to look sexy you have to dress the right way, which I think is not the message Sofia is trying to share.
ReplyDeleteIn this commercial Sofia is trying to portray that to be a woman in today's society you have to dress in a certain and look a particular way. According to Sofia the way a woman needs to dress is sexy and in the latest fashion. In this case Sofia's clothing line. This commercial works because women are desperate to look beautiful and sexy like Sofia. It appeals to women because Sofia shows that if you wear her clothing line you will be a sexy, trendy, true woman.
ReplyDeleteFor the most part I agree with what Nick said, especially with the hit or miss aspect of the commercial. The point where I differ with him is in the fact that I believe this commercial to be more about promoting her clothing line than telling women to be confident in themselves. Though it has well meaning intentions by the end I saw it as a commercial that shows a different body type with each shot with the intention that this clothing line is for everybody.
ReplyDeleteUnder Sophia's definition of how a woman dresses, a woman must dress sexy no matter what body type she has. This appeals to a wide range of audience due to the fact that in each shot, she introduces a new woman of a different ethnicity and/or body type wearing her line, meaning that it does not matter if a woman is White, Black, Hispanic, skinny or on the more hefty side, Sophia's line of clothing will make you sexy. This commercial works due to the fact that it plays on one of the biggest weaknesses woman have which is seeing if they too can be considered attractive. By including everyone, the brand designer has made a large audience market with which she can make a profit off of.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Alaina's comment on the desperation for woman to be sexy like Sophia, however i would like to suggest that there is an even broader underlying meaning. Even if the women who see the commercial do not want to be Sophia, by including the variety of demographics in the commercial, the women can substitute their own idols in Sophia's place but still achieve that sexy, trendy look.
ReplyDeleteI agree with what Anna said about the condescending nature of the commercial. She stated that by wearing Sophia Vergara's line of clothing, women will be "true women." Women are more than just figures in clothing and their beauty should not be determined solely by the clothes they wear.
ReplyDeleteI think that everyone represents very valid approaches to the commercial. They all show how the message of this commercial can be different to each individual. Anna supports herself well along with others with the same view. On the other side of the coin Richard backs up his views really well along with the other classmates that share the same philosophy. It makes it really easy to agree with my classmates when they all back up their responses so effectively.
ReplyDeleteI also agree with Anna. Women can be very proud of themselves without wearing "sexy" clothes. They can do many other things to make themselves proud. The only thing I was confused about was the positioning of the camera at certain points, especially at the end. It makes me think the commercial is attempting to appeal to men so, in turn, the men will tell their significant other to buy the product.
ReplyDeleteI think Cody is on to something... the positioning of the camera. It follows the women from the back, as they "strip" into the next lady and specifically on Sophia's chest. The fact that she signals the camera "person" to look up seems to be a blatant suggestion that we the viewer have been admiring her figure. Is this commercial shaping a woman to think that to be sexy she must appeal to men? Discuss!
ReplyDeleteI agree that women have more to be proud of than just wearing sexy clothing and that, in this commercial, Sofia Vergara seems to define women by their clothing. I would agree with Cody that the commercial uses camera angles to appeal to men as well, because there are plenty of scenes that are suggestive, such as showing off the woman's legs at 0:21 and showing Sophia's chest. It seems like the theme of the commercial is sexiness, and by making it an appealing commercial for men, it's also appealing to women since women want to look good for men. The commercial will also appeal to those who know Sofia Vergara from the show Modern Family and enjoy her acting.
ReplyDeleteI would say that Sofia's definition of being a woman is having the CONFIDENCE to step out of what most people would consider a comfortable and "usual" style, and take on a strong, "sexy" appearance. So by this definition, women ought to not hesitate when it comes to deciding whether or not they stand out and just wear what they want. As long as it makes them feel empowered as a woman; strong and confident. Also, to go along with Cody, sex sells. This commercial is definitely throwing a lot of images at you, peaking the interest of both men and women.
ReplyDeleteIn this commercial, Sophia Vergara shows every woman can be beautiful in the world. When wearing Sophia’s cloth, it describes the women who have confidence, beauty and proud. I think this commercial gives good opportunity to have confidence for women. When women start acting and go to auditions, they usually do not know how should be act like woman who has confidence because they are not voluptuous as Sophia Vergara. However, Sophia depicts every women can be voluptuous. Despite there are races of white, black and yellow, it eliminates racial prejudice. Therefore, because of this reason, the audiences of this commercial feel comfortable for watch.
ReplyDeleteAnna,
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with your comment; especially when you mentioned how the commercial tries to create appeal for a larger audience through the visualization of many different ethnicities! One thing I would like to add though is the fact that Sophia's clothing line is produced for Kmart. Another part of the appeal of the advertisement is that not only are the clothes attractive but the quality of the clothes appears to be of high standard for being sold at Kmart, an economic option for people on a budget. This may add to the appeal and effect of the commercial.
At first this commercial seems to not offend. It appears that it's just trying to advertise high-end clothes at a reasonable price. But if one takes a look back at what message this is sending out to women, they get a completely different feel For one, she is using sex to sell an item. This is not only disgusting but demoralizing to women across the globe. It says, "Hey, I have a nice rack, buy stuff from me." This sets a twisted standard for women. Glowing hair, smooth skin, and an emaciated frame. This makes girls all over look at themselves and make themselves think that they are ugly. IN order to be slightly more beautiful they have to buy her clothes. I think that it is a sick tactic indeed!!!
ReplyDelete@Cameron Bouchard
ReplyDeleteI agree with the fact that women should just wear what makes them comfortable, and not be subjected to the pressure put on them by advertisements, but that, sadly, isn't as easy to do as it is to think about. Even the many different women shown in the commercial to portray all the different bodies that can wear the clothing are all nearly flawless women in their own sense. This takes the attempt at making all women feel more comfortable about their bodies and turns it into self-doubt of a different manner.
In this commercial, Sophia Vergara, makes it clear that dressing like a woman means dressing to the sexy side less than conservative clothing. At the same time she is not portrtaying a poor messege towards women because the purpose of her clothes line is to get women of any budget to dress confidently and as her idea of a well-dressed woman.
ReplyDelete